Henry II was the first Plantagenet king, the dynasty which ruled over England for more than 300 years. The name Plantagenet comes from a flower that Henry’s father, Geoffrey of Anjou, used to wear. Henry reigned for 35 years. But his succession to the throne had been riddled by complications. Twenty years before Henry became king (in 1154), it was his mother, the Empress Matilda, who was heir to the throne of England.
Matilda had been married to the Holy Roman Emperor Henry V. On his death, she returned to England and the court of her father Henry I but retained the title of Empress. Her second marriage was to Geoffrey of Anjou. The match pleased neither of them but they got on with things and produced children including the future Henry II. Matilda was one of two legitimate children of Henry I and his first wife, Matilda of Scotland who died in 1118. The other child was a boy named William. As well as these two children, Henry I is believed to have sired as many as 24 illegitimate children with various mistresses. Henry probably should have spent more time focusing on producing further legitimate children as in 1120, disaster struck for his son and heir, William.
King Henry and the royal court had been on the continent but were preparing to return to England in the winter of 1120. Henry was to sail on one ship whilst William and other young members of the nobility were to sail on a ship that had been borrowed for the occasion, called the White Ship.
The White Ship soon became rowdy with youthful exuberance as those on board began to thoroughly enjoy themselves as they threw a party. Meanwhile, the more sombre ship carrying the king had already set off leaving the White Ship lagging behind. The now very drunk crew decided that they were going to remedy the fact they were so far behind by sailing at a pace where they could not only catch up but overtake the other vessel.
As you can well imagine, this was an idea fraught with dangers. Some on board recognised the dangers before it was too late. One man by the name of Stephen of Blois claimed to have a stomach complaint and disembarked. It was a sensible decision and saved Stephen’s life. It would also be a fateful one in English history as 15 years later, Stephen claimed the throne ahead of Matilda. Anyway, the White Ship, with its steaming drunk crew and passengers, set sail but almost immediately ran into grave problems. Almost before they had even left the harbour, the White Ship sailed straight into a rock and began to sink into the freezing water. Raucous cheers and laughter now turned into screams of terror and horror.
William, being the king’s heir, was bundled hastily into a lifeboat and would have survived the disaster had he not acted so bravely and so selflessly. In the midst of all the chaos, he heard the pitiable cries of his half sister, another Matilda (not to be confused with his full sister). The 17 year old prince ordered the boat to be turned about in order to save the life of Matilda but the boat was swamped as others desperate to save themselves tried to clamber into the boat. It capsized and into the water went William Aetheling. With his death, the course of English history changed forever.
The king and his party returned home safely. However, news soon filtered through about the disaster that had befallen the king in Barfleur harbour, just off the coast of Normandy. The magnitude of the event was not lost on any of the nobility and they were, understandably, frightened of telling the king the tragic news. In fact, so afraid were they of informing the king, the grown men of the nobility shirked their responsibility and instead got a terrified young boy to do the dirty work. When Henry had finally been told, he was devastated. Firstly, on a personal front, he had lost three children in the tragedy. William and two illegitimate children, Matilda, the young woman William had tried to save, and a son called Richard. This was a sorry tale for the king indeed.
But it was also a disaster for the king on a dynastic front too. With his heir dead, Henry had no obvious successor. He had one surviving daughter and a score of illegitimate children. England, at this time, expected a king who’d be able to ride into battle, if needed, and protect the realm from domestic and foreign adversaries. Simply because she was a woman, Empress Matilda would have been considered by many to be an inappropriate candidate for the throne. As time would tell, Henry would not share that line of thinking. However, he still recognised it would be preferable for him to produce another heir or two to secure the crown that had been won by his father, William The Conqueror, and produce a dynasty that would last generations and avoid civil war on Henry’s death which would tarnish his legacy.
Bearing all that in mind, Henry, a widower, did in fact marry again. His second wife was a young woman by the name of Adeliza of Louvain. Try as they might, the marriage failed to produce any children. This is almost certainly Henry’s own fault. Spending too much time with mistresses in his younger years had come back to haunt him. In the middle ages, kings didn’t just need one son; ideally, they’d produce several in the eventuality of premature death.This was a common sense route to take as infant mortality was high. Henry had been unlucky in one sense that William had survived infancy and was becoming a young man when he died but even then, there was no guarantee William would outlive his father. Henry should have produced spares. This is probably the biggest flaw of an otherwise competent and wise king.
Another reason to suspect that the reason for the barren marriage was Henry’s fault was that, after his death in 1135, Adeliza married again. This time she produced seven children. There was evidently nothing physically wrong with her. Henry’s overindulgence had come back to bite him.
Once it occurred to the old king that no more sons were forthcoming, he had to weigh up his options. He considered, for a time, making one of his illegitimate sons his heir. But, in the end, he settled on his daughter Matilda. One thing that may have swayed Henry in his decision making was that Matilda already had experience in administration. During her first marriage to the Holy Roman Emperor Henry V, she had played a significant role in Henry V’s governance, handling petitions and grants. Whatsmore,as I've discussed, after her return to England on Henry V’s death in 1125, she married again, albeit reluctantly, in 1128 to Geoffrey of Anjou and with him produced three sons, including the future Henry II in 1133.
The old king would have been delighted at the birth of his grandson and he showed it too. Chroniclers tell how the king took great pleasure in meeting the baby Henry and he proved to be a doting grandfather. In this little boy, the old king may have recognised a potential stabilising force in English politics as he knew Matilda’s succession would certainly not go uncontested.
Apart from his fondness for women, another of Henry’s vices was his love of lampreys, a type of eel. His doctors had warned him that too many could prove dangerous for him. And so it proved. In 1135, after another overindulgence, Henry became gravely ill. The time had come to ensure a smooth succession to the throne for his daughter. Henry gathered his nobles around his deathbed to ensure they swore loyalty to Matilda. But, deep down, Henry would have known this meant very little. His distrust of them was evident. This was the third time the nobility had been forced to make such an oath and just three weeks after the old king had died, England had a new monarch. And it wasn’t Matilda.
Stephen of Blois was crowned king of England just a few days before Christmas 1135. Almost immediately he faced challenges in his kingdom. The king of Scots, David I, invaded and captured Newcastle and Carlisle. Eager to look proactive to his new subjects, Stephen marched north to deal with the invasion. The campaign was not overly successful however and did little to improve Stephen’s public image. Although he regained control of Newcastle, Stephen settled for an agreement which meant David retained Carlisle. Perhaps Stephen decided he had more pressing priorities. In 1137, he reached an agreement with Empress Matilda’s husband, Geoffrey of Anjou to stave him off, for the time being at least, from capturing Normandy. Stephen largely had Henry I to thank for that. Stephen had inherited a kingdom in a healthy financial state and plenty of men at his disposal so this left him in a strong negotiating position with Geoffrey. However, the situation would change over time.
The following year, in 1138, the folly of Stephen’s weak capitulation to David I of Scotland was fully exposed as David once again invaded the north. There are graphic descriptions of atrocities carried out during this latest invasion. Some are almost certainly exaggerations but all the same these were worrying times for the king of England, Stephen, because of the weak agreement he had made in early 1136, had left the north of his kingdom extremely vulnerable to further attacks. In response to David’s provocation, Stephen led an expedition into the South of Scotland, burning and laying waste to enemy territory. Stephen returned southwards after getting word of trouble in the west country but while he was gone, David once again invaded. But he was defeated by Stephen’s northern nobility at the battle of the Standard. It’s somewhat ironic that Stephen’s biggest success so far is a victory in battle which he was hundreds of miles away from. All the same, it proved that the king did have significant support on his side. This was key for a usurper.
In 1139, Stephen’s rival for the throne, Matilda, finally arrived in England. Again, Stephen attempted to be proactive and besieged Matilda at Arundel. Again, he made a poor and rather weak decision. Rather than continuing the siege and keeping Matilda on the backfoot, he let Matilda slip away and she made her way to Bristol which was the power base of her key ally, her half brother Robert of Gloucester. Stephen now had a serious problem on his hands. In 1140, the king marched northwards to Lincoln which had fallen into the hands of his enemies. Stephen settled in for a potentially long siege. The man who had captured Lincoln was Ranulf, Earl of Chester, who also happened to be Robert of Gloucester’s son in law. Robert too journeyed to Lincoln in a bid to relieve the siege and here, the forces loyal to Matilda and the king’s army met in battle in 1141.
When battle became inevitable, Stephen had one of his nobles, called Baldwin, give a rousing speech to his soldiers. Stephen himself didn’t give the speech due to his weak speaking voice. The king spent the morning before the battle taking mass and asking for divine assistance against his enemies. No help was forthcoming.
To credit Stephen, he did not shy away from the battle and he threw himself into the midst of the throng and fought bravely. His acts so far as king had been largely uninspiring but he would have impressed his men by his conduct at Lincoln. However, he and his army were soon overwhelmed and Stephen was captured.
This now appeared to leave the throne clear for Matilda. With the king now taken into custody at Bristol, Matilda made preparations to journey to London where she’d have herself crowned. Unfortunately, it didn’t prove as straightforward as that for her as the people of London despised her. Matilda was accused of being pompous and insufferably arrogant. It’s not beyond the realms of possibility that the Empress was a little on the arrogant side. She had, after all, retained her imperial title which may be a sign of a slightly inflated ego. But Matilda’s personality would have been criticised regardless of what traits she had. There would have been considerable pushback to the idea of a female ruler. Indeed, Matilda’s reliance on Robert of Gloucester may have given that some credibility. He was the one that was leading the fight against Stephen. However, this does not get away from the fact that Matilda was the rightful heir to Henry I and there’s a good chance, had she succeeded, the civil war may have been avoided or at least not have dragged on as long as it did.
Either way, Matilda was rejected by the people of London and forced to flee. Then, even worse was to follow for her. Robert of Gloucester was captured by forces loyal to Stephen. This was a calamity and Matilda knew it. In the end, if Matilda harboured any realistic hopes of gaining the crown then she needed Robert and his release was agreed in exchange for the release of king Stephen.
This would have been a relief to Stephen but his reign was hardly in a good state. He had been defeated and captured in battle by his enemies and in 1144, he lost Normandy to Matilda’s husband, Geoffrey of Anjou. The rest of Stephen’s reign was dominated by him struggling to stamp his authority on his kingdom as he lost control of places like Worcester. This was a destructive time in English history, known as “The Anarchy”, and not much good can be said of it. One description of the period goes,” a time when Christ and his angels slept.”.
Ironically though, Stephen did make one significant, long lasting contribution to the security of the English crown. A man by the name of John Marshall had been causing the king significant problems and, as a result, one of Marshall’s young sons, a boy named William, was handed over to the king as surety for his father’s good behaviour. However, John almost disregarded this and continued to cause bother for Stephen. There are kings who may well have executed William as punishment for John’s behaviour, despite the fact that William was only 5 years old at the time. There are, sadly, examples of similar situations in the middle ages. However, Stephen spared the boy. It’s said, one day, that Stephen had overheard the little William talking to one of the king’s soldiers, asking to play with his spear. This had touched the king and he took William under his care. William Marshall remembered this kindness and he would go on to become one of the greatest knights in medieval history who, time and again, saved the English crown from calamity. Stephen was a man who had shown himself to be someone who could be self interested and his reign had been weak. But he was also not a malicious man and this act is one worthy of praise.
By this point, we are in the early 1150s and Stephen has another challenger to his reign. This is Matilda’s son, Henry. Henry launched a rather hopeful expedition to overthrow Stephen despite being just a teenager. Again, Stephen shows a side to him that’s not as ruthless as other kings. Rather than having the rather pitiful invasion swiftly dealt with and taking Henry into custody, he simply paid the boy off. Perhaps, by this stage, Stephen was beginning to give up on the idea of establishing a long dynasty of his family ruling over England, weary of years of fighting. And so it came to pass in 1153. A treaty was signed at Wallingford that agreed to make Henry Stephen’s heir, disinheriting Stephen’s own son who died not long after. Although Matilda had never gained the crown that she had deserved, this was the next best thing. Little did she know, her son, the soon to be Henry II, would be the first king of the dynasty that would rule England for over 300 years.